Canadians are finally learning there is no constitutional right to abortion
Over the past number of years, abortion advocates and politicians have repeatedly been telling Canadians a terrible lie (which mainstream media outlets have continually reported as a fact); namely, that the Charter of Rights and Freedoms embedded within the Canadian Constitution guarantees women a fundamental “right to abortion”.
“Today was about improving access with a 1-800 number to provide the service to Island women that the Supreme Court decided upon over 30 years ago.”
“I totally respect the Supreme Court and the ruling that they have provided in regards to this being a Constitutional issue and that there is an obligation for all provinces to provide services.”
“Hajdu’s nod to ‘hard-won rights’ is a reference to the Supreme Court’s landmark 1988 Morgentaler decision. But that decision didn’t recognize a constitutional right to abortion under the Charter. While it did nullify Canada’s existing abortion law, the Court left it to Parliament to come up with new legislation that would balance the rights of women with the state’s interest in the protection of the fetus, within the bounds of the charter.”
….or the following from the Ottawa Citizen on January 16, 2018:
Rev. Moyle responds: “There is no constitutional right to an abortion,” but there is to freedom of religion.
….or the following from CBC’s program The Current on January 15, 2018:
Blaise Alleyne, the president of Toronto and Area Right to Life, has filed a claim in federal court, arguing that it is the government, not anti-abortion groups, who are contravening the Charter. “If you read the Morgentaler decision, there is actually no Charter right to abortion,” he tells The Current‘s Anna Maria Tremonti. “But there is a Charter right to freedom of expression, freedom of conscience, freedom of religion, and equality rights. So this is a charter challenge.”
….or many, many other similar statements in numerous provincial, regional and national news outlets. This is something entirely new. And it’s powerful. It represents, I believe, an important step in the struggle to fully expose and banish the lie that we have no choice but to allow Canadian women to abort roughly 100,000 babies each year in Canada because the most important law in our country – the Constitution – tells us we must!
Yes, it’s true that there is still no federal “law” to recognize the rights of unborn children to continuing living – a law that, as the Supreme Court stated, would “put reasonable limitations on abortion;” but as more and more Canadians are realizing that millions of other Canadians just like them DON’T support abortion, and that abortion is not, in fact, a Charter Right…..well, for the first time in a long time this sudden and growing awareness makes it far more likely that provincial governments – or at least some provincial political parties, especially the Progressive Conservative Party in PEI – will now give serious consideration to whether funding “medically-unnecessary” abortions should continue to take precedence over funding “life-giving” medical procedures or services which are currently not being funded.
I would, therefore, respectfully ask opposition politicians, especially Hon. James Aylward, leader of the PEI PC Conservative Party, to take a careful look at the Case I prepared, ask their own legal counsel to provide an opinion on the merits of the case and likelihood of a challenge being successful, and if that opinion is favourable, which it should be, submit a question to the PEI Supreme Court asking for a ruling on whether the current abortion policy is breaking the law by funding abortions which are not medically required. All the work has already been done, so it shouldn’t cost anything much to take it forward. A little courage to do the right thing and a sense of duty to hold the government accountable to not break the law is really all that’s required.
Article Comments
Anonymous
February 21, 2018 2:54 pmThank-you for your good work. God bless you for speaking the truth.