Act Does Not Oblige Abortions
The Following Letter to the Editor appeared in the Guardian newspaper on January 26th; it addresses a key inaccuracy in an article reporting on a recent Pro-Life demonstration in Summerside.


In Tuesday’s Guardian editorial, ‘Fact check everything,’ we read:
“We have to be more careful than ever to be accurate. We also have to be ready to clearly identify and call out mistakes and lies for what they are, when they occur. We want you to consider the source, and not find us wanting.”
I sincerely commend the Guardian for taking the journalistic high road. I also want to take you up on your offer.
An article in Monday’s Guardian, “Anti-abortionists rally outside PCH,” stated:
“The Canada Health Act states that everyone in Canada should have access to necessary health services, including abortion.”
Abortion is nowhere legally defined as a necessary health service in Canada. Nor does the Canada Health Act state that “… everyone should have access to necessary health services, including abortion.” The word abortion is nowhere mentioned in the CHA.
The Constitution grants provinces exclusive jurisdiction to determine which medical procedures are funded under provincial health plans. The federal law and government division, in “Abortion: Constitutional and Legal Developments,” says,
“The state is required only to respect such decisions, or to refrain from interfering with them, not to approve or facilitate them. . . . .A province can limit coverage for abortions by regulation, provided there is authority in the governing Act to make such a regulation.”
The P.E.I. Health Services Act clearly conveys such authority. It is entirely within P.E.I.’s jurisdictional and legal right to neither offer nor pay for abortions.
Leave a Comment Cancel Comment
Judicial Review of PEI’s Abortion Policy and Law
September 4, 2023
Court File No: SIGS27017 . SUPREME COURT OF PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND (GENERAL SECTION) BETWEEN: KEVIN J. ARSENAULT Applicant and THE GOVERNMENT OF PRINCE EDWARD ISLAND, as represented by the MINISTER...
And the Winner for the Most False Accusations in a Single Guest Opinion is…..Richard Deaton (Applause, Applause)
March 19, 2018
Richard Deaton published a Guest Opinion in the Guardian on March 6, 2018 titled “The Changing Politics of Abortion,” which then appeared in the Journal Pioneer the following day....
Progressive Catholics Don’t Abort Babies
March 3, 2018
‘It is not ‘progressive’ to try to resolve problems by eliminating a human life’ [Published as a Guest Opinion in The Guardian September 20, 2017] Richard Deaton’s September 15 Guardian...
Province has no legal obligation to fund abortions
March 3, 2018
How many times must it be stated that there is no constitutional right to abortion in Canada? This fact is repeatedly and stubbornly ignored by those pushing for abortion access...
Pope continues to reject abortion
March 3, 2018
[Published as a “Letter to the Editor” in the Guardian, April 21, 2015] A recent Guardian editorial accuses Bishop Grecco of intruding into the P.E.I. election campaign on abortion, stating...
Article Comments
Barb MacFarlane
January 26, 2017 12:38 pmThank you, Kevin, for bringing this factual information to the general public. It is much-needed information. Barb