Murphy’s Law For PEI Taxpayers

Murphy's Law for PEI Taxpayers

Now that Teresa Wright is finished at the Guardian, there’s a good chance lots of interesting news will never hit print or find its way onto Louise Martin’s desk at CBC.

If you really want to know about the big important decisions being made by Wade MacLauchlan you have to read the Orders in Council on Executive Council’s webpage. 

That’s something Teresa knew well.

So I thought I’d take a peek at the decisions from just two meetings: February 21 & 27 to see what struggling businesses on our mighty Island are getting the financial help they need and deserve so they can be successful like, say, the Murphy Group of companies.  Island Investment Development Inc. can authorize small loans, but need Cabinet approval for bigger chunks of taxpayer’s hard-earned money, pursuant to subsection 2(3) of the Island Investment Development Act Financial Assistance Regulations (EC2005-686):

2 (3) On the application of a person, the Corporation may, with the approval of the Lieutenant Governor in Council, advance a loan or a loan guarantee to a person if the total indebtedness of the person to the Corporation, including guarantees provided by the Corporation on behalf of that person or an affiliate of that person, exceeds $2,500,000 in the aggregate.

Surprisingly, there were only 3 loan applications to IIDI requiring Cabinet approval dealt with at the February 21st & 27th Meetings:

(A)  On February 21, Cabinet authorised Island Investment Development Inc. to advance a loan in the amount of $600,000.00 to Great George Properties Ltd [owned by Kevin Murphy] in one decision;   and another $2,140,000.00 loan to Prince Edward Island Brewing Company Ltd. [also owned by Kevin Murphy] in another decision.

(B) On February 27, Cabinet authorised Island Investment Development Inc. to advance a loan for $4,000,000.00 to company # 102163 P.E.I. Inc., [phew!….at least it wasn’t the Murphy clan again…or was it?  I checked the Corporate/Business Registry on the Department of Justice and Community Affairs website and lo and behold, company #102163 PEI Inc.  has just one director who is also the only shareholder, Paul William Murphy….Kevin Murphy’s nephew. What kind of business is #102163? Under “Business Type” all that is listed is “Business Corporation,” so your guess is as good as mine.

And that’s why on PEI we have such fondness for citing Murphy’s law: “Whatever can go wrong [for taxpayers] will go wrong,” given the fact that the Murphy’s are hard-core Liberal insiders and Wade’s remaining time to write them cheques is slowly but surely coming to a close.


  1. I wonder if I could get a loan to get a new roof!? Oh wait I’m the working poor/ taxpayer that is funding those (loans). Guess I’ll live with my leaky roof.

  2. The swamp is deep! Great work Kevin. I always look forward to your views. As they’re well researched and have what would be called “truth” attached to them. It’ll soon be time to change the guard here on PEI.

    1. Dear Anonymous: I didn’t say loans are gifts in the above article so I’m not sure what point you are making….I think it is obvious that loans are not gifts or “grants” (e.g., totally free money). However, it is worth pointing out that sometimes – in fact far too often – government loans turn into total gifts. For the 2013-14 fiscal year, for example, the board of directors of Finance P.E.I. authorized the cancellation of 3.7 million of government loans.

      With as much wealth and collateral as the Murphys have, surely they would not have a problem borrowing from the banks, so why are they routinely borrowing from taxpayers? The terms and conditions aren’t disclosed in the executive council orders, but you can be sure they’re getting far more favourable interest rates (if they’re paying interest at all) and receiving other preferable terms and conditions than they would get from chartered banks, so whatever amount of money they are “saving” from not having to borrow from banks (like other Islanders and most Island businesses must do) you can accurately call a “gift” .

Have a Comment on this Article You'd Like to Share?